UTOPIA: ON ITS ETHICS, POLITICS, & ECONOMICS

The lessons from the previous essay, How Congress Works--jk

Home
THE LOVE OF ALL THINGS, A FOUNDATION FOR ETHICS--jk
Selflessness, The Good, and Happiness--jk
Happiness & Scientific Psychology--jk
The Art of Loving: A Behaviorist Approach--jk
A Lesson on Love from Cats--jk
THE DECALOGUE: Greek Moral Philosophy Modernized--jk
THE GOOD LIFE--Greek Philosophers Teachings
SOCIAL JUSTICE: FIVE STEPS FORWARD--jk
No Free Lunches: The Role of the Stock Market--jk
UTOPIAN ECONOMICS--jk
Plato's Dream Fulfilled by Science--jk
The lessons from the previous essay, How Congress Works--jk
AMERICAN JUSTICE (poem)--jk
A PHILOSOPHER'S COMMENTS ON THE CURRENT PATHOS--jk
WAR ON DRUGS: COSTS--jk
EINSTEIN DEFENDS SOCIALISM
STATS ON WORLD POVERTY
On Dying Atheist: A Doctor's Words
SATIRE ON PRISON LIFE

A HOUSE DIVIDED: Why asking Congress to perfrom two often contradictory jobs--legislating and overseeing--is asking for trouble.

David Segal

The Washington Monthly, Jan/Feb, 1994

CONGRESS AT WORK, A DOSE OF REALITY


THE ONE THING YOU CAN BE SURE YOUR COBGRESSMAN STANDS FOR IS THAT OF GETTING ELECTED.--P.J. O'Rouke, from "The Parliment of Whores".

The account of how Congress through its appropriation power and use of committees runs our bureaucracy and guides the production of contractors is revealed in the example of McDonnell Douglas C-17, the giant military cargo transport plane. Over and over gain on programs such as "60 Minutes" we learn of Congress failures in the area of supervision. David Segals article exposes its mechanism.



ESSENTIAL ELEMENTS OF FAILURE

Conflict:
1. Each branch of the military is seeking a bigger chunk of the federal budget. They thus exaggerate the need, effectiveness, and costs of weapon systems. Since they don't control the purse strings

2. Like the military, contractor also exaggerate the costs and effectiveness and delivery date of the system they are developing.

3. Congressmen have objectives which are inconsistent with their role of regulating the working of government


OPERATIONS AND CONFLICTS:
a. Many of those on the committee have a vested interest in funding programs good for the industry they are regulating, because that industry is a major employer in their district/state.

b. Those who lobby for an industry as well as individual corporations are permitted to make substantial election contributions. Those who pay the piper select the tune.

c. Congressmen are more concerned with getting into the press than performing their oversight duties.

d. Hearings resemble product commercials, rather than investigation of expenditures.

e. Peer pressure to get along.

f. Back scratching; VIZ., I vote for your bill, you vote for mine.

g. Industries are permitted to make donations to them for reelection, to given them plane tickets, honoraria, and other gifts.

h. As long as a single committee is supposed to provide funding and oversight, then any exposure of abuse smears themselves (who do the funding).

The political realities give Congress a different agenda. There are 247 committees and 127,000 staff employees. Each Congressman sits on several committees. Most of the efforts of this staff has little to do with exposing and correcting the problems connected to the function of the particular oversight committee.

Given that over half of the work time a Congressman spends is in activites related to getting votes, there is little time left for the several committes they belong to, other than attending their meatings and reading prepared statements into the record (JK's addition).

Since the military does not control the purse strings, they tend to work with the contractors in their deceptions rather than to expose them, for to expose them could result in the cutting of funding for a weapons system.

Congress role should be to obtain the best possible armament for the percentage of the federal budget so allocated, and in particular to serve the best interests of all the people within the traditionally established limits.

Things have changed since the World War Two. The press is much less interested in exposure of abuse in government--measured by television news content. Exposing abuse is thus not nearly so effective in producing name recognition, as it was in Truman's time. And being not so effective entails that as per reelction the rewards are much less.

Enter supporting content here

powered by lycos
SEARCH:Tripod The Web