On the Bear Stearns Situation
From $20 Billion to 236 Million
Hale “Bonddad” Stewart, 3/17/08
Pushed to the brink of collapse by the mortgage crisis, Bear Stearns Cos. agreed -- after prodding
by the federal government -- to be sold to J.P. Morgan Chase & Co. for the fire-sale price of $2 a share in stock, or
about $236 million.
had a stock-market value of about $3.5 billion as of Friday -- and was worth $20 billion in January 2007. But the crisis of
confidence that swept the firm and fueled a customer exodus in recent days left Bear Stearns with a horrible choice: sell
the firm -- at any price -- to a big bank willing to assume its trading obligations or file for. "At the end of the day, what
Bear Stearns was looking at was either taking $2 a share or going bust," said one person involved in the negotiations. "Those
were the only options."
To help facilitate
the deal, the Federal Reserve is taking the extraordinary step of providing as
much as $30 billion in financing for Bear Stearns's less-liquid assets, such as
mortgage securities that the firm has been unable to sell, in what is believed to be the largest Fed advance on record to
a single company. Fed officials wouldn't describe the exact financing terms or assets involved. But if those assets decline
in value, the Fed would bear any loss, not J.P. Morgan.
Secretary Robert Rubin last week described the situation as "uncharted waters," a view echoed privately by top government
officials. Those officials have been scrambling to come up with new tools because the old ones aren't suited for this 21st-century
crisis, in which financial innovation has rendered many institutions not "too big too fail," but "too interconnected to be
allowed to fail suddenly."
Let's make some
-- For all practical
purposes, Bear Stearns is bankrupt. Despite the shotgun nature of the Bear/JP Morgan deal, Bear would not have agreed
to a $2/share valuation unless the damage to their business was extremely severe.
-- JPM swooped
in quickly on this deal. My guess is they have been watching this situation for some time and waited for the right moment
to get this deal. All the players lined up too quickly in JPM's favor for this to be a happy coincidence. JPM sees a play
here and went for it. This actually is good news. If there are other firms in financial straights right now, others
know about it. The Fed has demonstrated they will help to finance the deal. In short, if another firm goes bankrupt it will
be a quick procedure to deal with it.
-- The Federal
Reserve is scared shitless. There is no reason for them to get involved in this deal unless they were worried about one
of two things (and probably both): 1.) the ripple effect and/or 2.) other banks in a similar situation. The Fed is looking
for any tool (and making some new ones up) to prevent a system wide crisis.
-- Last week
S&P announced the end of the writedowns at the big banks was near an end. Almost on cue, events demonstrated how hapless
S&P has become when it comes to credit analysis.
To combat further
problems, the Fed has lowered the discount rate and expanded its credit facilities.:
The Federal Reserve, struggling to prevent a meltdown in financial markets, cut the rate on direct
loans to banks and became lender of last resort to the biggest dealers in U.S. government bonds.
In its first weekend emergency action in almost three decades, the central bank lowered the so-called
discount rate by a quarter of a percentage point to 3.25 percent. The Fed also will lend to the 20 firms that buy Treasury
securities directly from it. In a further step, the Fed will provide up to $30 billion to JPMorgan Chase & Co. to help
it finance the purchase of Bear Stearns Cos. after a run on Wall Street's fifth-largest securities firm.
``It is a serious extension of putting the Federal Reserve's balance sheet in harm's way,'' said Vincent
Reinhart, former director of the Division of Monetary Affairs at the Fed and now a scholar at the American Enterprise Institute
in Washington. ``That's got to tell you the economy is in a pretty precarious state.''
The move is Chairman Ben S. Bernanke's latest step to alleviate a seven-month credit squeeze that's
probably pushed the U.S. into a recession. The dollar tumbled to a 12-year low against the yen and Treasury notes rallied
as traders increased bets that officials will reduce their main rate by 1 percentage point when they meet tomorrow.
`Race to the Bottom'
``Clearly, the Fed is trying to provide more liquidity to prevent a more vicious cycle and race to
the bottom,'' said Gary Schlossberg, senior economist at Wells Capital Management in San Francisco, which oversees $200 billion.
``The problem is there's so much concern about credit quality that now there are solvency issues, and it's something the Fed
has a more difficult time dealing with.''
I was listening to Bloomberg this morning and someone commented that Bernanke is a student of the great
depression and that knowledge was serving him well. I agree with that sentiment. I have made a great deal of fun at Bernanke's
expense over the past few months. Frankly, I feel a great deal of empathy for him because he is between a rock and hard place.
However, I understand
his reasoning for taking these moves. Simply put, Bernanke is trying to prevent a financial sector meltdown.
The central problem
the Fed faces right now is their tools are not designed for the problems we face. What we have right now is a collateral
and counter-party crisis. That means two things.
1.) The collateral
crisis means that collateral on bank's balance sheets isn't performing as well as advertised. Basically, any bond backed
by mortgages is in trouble because homeowners aren't paying their mortgages. That means banks who hold mortgages aren't getting
the payments they should be getting. As a result, banks balance sheets -- which serve as the basis for their ability to extend
credit -- are in serious trouble. That means...
2.) Anyone who
might take out a loan might not pay it back. This is called counter-party risk. It simply means that everyone is at
risk of defaulting on a loan right now. That means loans aren't getting made. In an economy like the US economy where credit
is a prerequisite to everything, that is the kiss of death.
The Fed can provide
plenty of money. Over the last 9 months they have flooded the market with cash. But that does not good if people aren't
willing to use it. And right now, no one wants to loan anybody any money. That's the central problem -- and so long as
that exists there will be a mis-match between the Fed's policy tools and the market's problems.
Let's look to
This week Bear, Goldman Sachs (GS), Lehman Brothers (LEH) and Morgan Stanley (MS) are slated to report
results for their first quarter, ended in February. The results won't be pretty.
The new name on everybody's lips is Lehman Brothers:
Lehman Brothers Holdings Inc. Monday said the bank's liquidity position remains strong, as the fire
sale of Bear Stearns to J.P. Morgan to prevent bankruptcy increased speculation that other big U.S. brokerages would come
position is and continues to be strong," said Matthew Russell, head of corporate communications for Lehman Brothers Asia Pacific.
came after people familiar with the situation said DBS Group Holdings, Southeast Asia's biggest bank by market capitalization,
has asked several traders not to enter new transactions with Lehman Brothers.
"DBS has sent
an internal e-mail saying it would not deal with Lehman Brothers from now on. It said DBS shouldn't enter into new dealings
with Lehman or Bear Stearns," one person said. Another person said
that the email didn't mention anything about closing existing positions with Lehman, which appear to remain in place for now.
DBS's move follows
the near-collapse of Bear Stearns Cos. Friday, a similar pullback by counterparties caused the bank's liquidity to dry up.
J.P. Morgan Chase & Co. Monday agreed to buy Bear Stearns for $2 a share in a bid to avert a bankruptcy by the U.S. investment
Since the middle of August,
when the collapse of U.S. subprime mortgages started to infect
markets around the world. Since then, the S&P 500 stocks index has dropped 11 percent and the dollar has fallen 15 percent
against the euro.
The central bank on March 11 announced it will for the first time lend
Treasuries in exchange for debt that includes mortgage-backed securities held by dealers to facilitate market- making. It
holds about $713 billion of Treasuries on its balance sheet.
On March 7, the Fed said it would make $100 billion available through
repurchase agreements, where the Fed loans cash in return for assets including mortgage debt issued by Fannie Mae and Freddie